The New York Giants
Hear it here!
This week is about the least likely team to be in first place at this juncture of the NFL season.
I’m talking about the New York Giants who have been underachievers for so long. But now they have a chance to not only show improvement, not only earn a playoff spot, but actually win their division race. There is no question it is one of the weaker divisions in the league, but that’s irrelevant.
A team does not control what others do, only themselves. And so far, they’re doing a pretty good job of handling what comes their way.
When I offered my pre-season NFL thoughts in early September, I knew, as I always do, that if you do a little better than break even on your hunches, you get a passing grade. Easy for me to say when I’m not the judge and jury. Our readers and listeners are.
One item I broached had to do with which, if any of the new head coaching hires made during the off-season, would make an impact.
My answer was John Harbaugh.
We have a long, long way to go in the 2026 campaign, but John Harbaugh has already made his imprint on one of the most fabled franchises in pro football annals.
Harbaugh became available to the Giants when they fired their head coach. and the Baltimore Ravens fired Harbaugh as their head coach. Harbaugh had a successful run with the Ravens winning a Super Bowl, and many playoff victories and division titles.
But lately the Ravens finished in sour fashion, and their owner, a good football man, felt it was time to make a change. The coach might have agreed with him.
So John Harbaugh entered a new chapter in his life, and at the least, he is off to a good start.
I know the man, not very well, but have been in his presence enough to make a judgment.
He is a straight-shooter. He is comfortable with who he is. He is a leader who players believe in.
The reason is that they know he can be tough when it calls for and be warm and applauding when that is called for. He is a man of Faith. It is the foundation of his life. Not for show. For real.
He lost his promising second-year quarterback Jaxson Dart in the season opener when the Giants beat the Cowboys. Two major linebackers are also out and there have been other injuries which all teams face. But when you’re 6-11, 3-14, and 4-13 in your last three seasons, key injuries seem more severe.
Last Sunday, the Giants outlasted the decimated Eagles who were down to their third quarterback of the year. But the Giants are as well. Their pickup of J.J. McCarthy from the Vikings appears to be to be more than merely a spark. But even McCarthy had to come out of the Eagles game for a spell. The fact is the Giants are not playing like a dominant division-leading team does. But they have been a resourceful, battling group that wears its collective hearts on their sleeve. They scrap and claw, rally and hold-on. Thus far, they have done what’s needed to survive and have found ways of winning games. Their record of five wins, two losses, and one tie is good enough at this point to lead the NFC East with a little room to breathe. The Cowboys are wildly inconsistent, the Commanders are so-so, and the pre-season favorite Eagles, Super Bowl champs only two years ago, have reached rock-bottom with seven straight defeats.
So I credit John Harbaugh who has always exhibited poise and quiet leadership.
Interesting as well is his choice of offensive coordinator, the man who calls the plays.
Matt Nagy, was the head coach of the Chicago Bears several years ago. He started on a bright note by earning a playoff berth in his first year. Then things went downhill. They usually do when a team does not have a franchise quarterback. Nagy was fired and returned to the Chiefs where he served as a senior assistant and quarterbacks coach for Patrick Mahomes. He had been the offensive coordinator in Kansas City prior to joining the Bears.
But his second tour of duty in K.C. didn’t work out so well, and parted ways after his contract expired. He admitted to Harbaugh in their interview for the Giants position that he had scars from his experiences in Chicago and lately in Kansas City. Nagy also interviewed in vain for the head coaching post with the Tennessee Titans.
But Harbaugh took a shot with Nagy, who has had to juggle an offense with three different quarterbacks and a running back group marked by injuries and ineffectiveness.
Nagy is a happy man. Calls himself lucky. He’s learning a great deal from the leadership side from Harbaugh. We all know things can and do change in the sports universe.
But what John Harbaugh has established in leading the New York Giants to a relatively rapid turnaround from the doldrums is refreshing and then some.
So the least likely division leader halfway through the NFL season is there because the man who has gotten them there was probably the most likely one to get it done.
Solid choice by the Giants
Getting it done against the Eagles
Matt Nagy a happy man


